Best historic hotels in Fishers Island, New York

Find the historic charm that Fishers Island has to offer by reserving a historic hotel. Ditch the boringness and run of the mill rooms that chain hotels offer and opt to stay in a hotel that has stood the test of time. It is no coincidence that these historic hotels, historic bed and breakfasts, and historic inn and suites are still in business. Vintage hotels provide charm and elegance that new builds and chains can’t compare. If you are having trouble deciding which historic hotel is right for you, then take it from us and reserve one of our favorite historic hotels in Fishers Island below.

Budget-Friendly Historic Hotels in Fishers Island

The great thing about historic hotels is they range in price and ratings, so finding a cheap historic hotel in Fishers Island is not a problem. If you want to get away to Fishers Island and stay in a historic bed and breakfast or historic inn, we suggest Comfort Suites Near Casinos, Americas Best Value Inn New London Mystic, or Hilltop Inn & Suites - North Stonington. These are some of the best historic hotels that Fishers Island has to offer, with historic charm, architecture, and quaintness that only vintage hotels can provide.

Luxury Historic Hotels In Fishers Island

Reserving a historic luxury hotel in Fishers Island is a great idea! Booking a room at a luxury hotel will safeguard you are staying at one of the best hotels Fishers Island has to offer. When you reserve a vintage luxury hotel, you will get all the allure and uniqueness of historic buildings. Copper Beech Inn, Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa, and Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa are some of our favorite historic hotels near Fishers Island. Even though these hotels are historical, their amenities aren’t. Some of the modern amenities you will get are Massage Services, Business center, On-site Restaurant, and Luxury Bedding. Reservations.com makes planning easy. Reserve your historic hotel with us for stress-free experiential travel planning.

Best Rated Historic Hotels In Fishers Island

There are excellent historic hotels, historic inns, and historic bed and breakfast in Fishers Island. If you want to stay at one of the best rated historic accommodations in the city, then reserve a room at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, or The Fox Tower at Foxwoods. These hotel options are our top-rated historic hotels in Fishers Island, according to previous guests. For more information about the hotel like hotel address, pictures, and amenities provided, click the link and explore the hotel page. You can also read previous guest reviews. Reserving a vintage hotel in Fishers Island allows you to experience the true essence of Fishers Island see the architecture and traditional aspects that made Fishers Island what it is today.

Make your Fishers Island Hotel Search Easy

Fishers Island Hotels by Brand

Fishers Island Hotels By Star Rating

Fishers Island Hotels by Amenities

Accommodation Types in Fishers Island

Theme Hotels in Fishers Island

The Taber Inne & Suites

66 Williams Avenue, Mystic CT - 6355

(855) 516-1090

5.28 miles

Recreational amenities at the hotel include an indoor pool, a fitness center, and complimentary bicycles. The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.

The Spa at Norwich Inn

607 W Thames St, Norwich CT - 6360

(855) 516-1090

16.74 miles

Wi-Fi, Two Pools, A Spa And A Restaurant All Meet In A Secluded Woodland Setting At The Non-Smoking Spa At Norwich Inn. All 99 Rooms At The Non-Smoking, Two-Story Spa At Norwich Inn Have Wi-Fi, Alarm Clock Radios, Bathtubs, Cd Players, Kitchenettes And Cable Tvs. Data Ports Are Available And There'S Nightly Turndown Service With Chocolates. The Property Features A Casino, A Golf Course, An Indoor And A Seasonal Outdoor Pool, A Hot Tub, Shopping, A Restaurant And A Lounge. There Is Also A Business Center With Copy, Translation And Secretarial Services, A Barber And Beauty Shop, Tennis Courts And A Terrace, And Laundry Service Is Available. Parking Is Free And Plentiful. Located On An Expansive 42-Acre Property In Eastern Connecticut Near The 17Th Tee Of The Norwich Public Golf Course, The Picturesque Spa At Norwich Inn Is Dotted With Perennial Gardens. Foxwoods Resort Casino Is A 10-Mile Drive, And It'S Less Than Three Miles From The City Center. It Is 20 Miles From T.F. Green International Airport.

Old Lyme Inn

85 Lyme Street, Old Lyme CT - 6371

(855) 516-1090

18.24 miles

Located Off Interstate 95, This Historical Inn Boasts Free Wi-Fi And Air-Conditioned Rooms With A Flat-Screen Cable Tv. Town Beach Is 12 Minutes’ Driving Distance.Rooms At The Old Lyme Inn Feature A New England Setting. Each Room Offers Luxury Bedding, An Ipod Docking Station And A Modern En-Suite Bathroom With Crabtree & Evelyn Toiletries. Select Rooms Provide A Gas Fireplace.An On-Site Restaurant Offers Guests A Seasonal Menu For Lunch Or Dinner.A Patio With Outside Seating Can Be A Perfect Place For Guests To Relax During Summer Months.Fort Saybrook Monument Park Is 6 Miles Away. Old Saybrook Railway Station And Shopping Centre Is Less Than 15 Minutes’ Drive. Old Lyme Country Club Is 1 Mile Away.

Show more results

Reserve